Lenten Reflection: “Let Me Prove It To You” | Mark 2:1-12

This probably won’t happen every morning, but something I am trying as a Lenten discipline is to take a little time each morning and write a brief reflection on the gospel text from the daily lectionary cycle. Today’s reflection is based on the reading from Mark 2:1-12.

I sometimes hear it suggested, in scholarly discussions of the New Testament, that there is a clear progression in the “Christology”— theological study focused on the identity and work of Christ— of the four gospel writers. Usually, it is said that John, the latest of the writers, puts the most emphasis on Christ’s deity and that Mark, the earliest writer, puts the most emphasis on his humanity. Sometimes, this is taken even farther to suggest that Christ is not divine in the early gospel writers, that the divinity of Christ is a later amendment by the Christian community to their understanding of who Jesus was.

I take such statements to be proof that some scholars of the Bible are really bad at reading literature.

Case and point: our text this morning.

Jesus returns to Capernaum, the home of James and Peter. He sits in a house teaching and is packed in by the crowd that gathers. Then the roof caves in. Well… kind of. Four guys cut a hole in it and lower their friend down into the crowd right in front of Jesus.

Now what happens next is taken by a lot of Christians as a statement on the deep spiritual need of all humans for forgiveness. I don’t contest that we have such a need, but I don’t think that’s the point of this particular story.

Rather, it seems to me that Jesus is being intentionally provocative.

He knows what the scribes are going to think of his statement to the paralyzed man. “‘Your sins are forgiven,’ who can say that but God alone??”

To which Jesus responds, “let me prove to you that I have the authority to make such a statement.”

Now what is the significance of offering such a proof? And why do it this way?

I think this story is a rather brilliant maneuver by Jesus. Without making any explicit statements, he has just told the scribes that he is God incarnate. And he’s done it by way of a public miracle in the midst of, effectively, a private conversation happening between him and the scribes.

Mark’s presentation of this story, then, isn’t an explicit declaration that Jesus is divine. But it certainly was meant to imply as much.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Lenten Reflection: “Let Me Prove It To You” | Mark 2:1-12

    1. Hey Alison! I’m not sure if this will totally answer the question you are asking, but I think I would distinguish between the two by saying that “being divine” is an inherent quality and “being given divine authority” is something bestowed and so “contingent” on that bestowal. So, for example, lately I’ve become slightly addicted to the show “Game of Thrones.” In the mythical world of the show, there is always someone who is acting as “Hand of the King,” which is basically the King’s chief advisor. That individual has a tremendous amount of authority to act “in the name of the king,” but only in so far as the king recognizes/supports them. Their authority is “bestowed” power and it only exists when the King decrees that it is to be so bestowed.

      That’s not a perfect analogy, but hopefully that makes some sense. Someone “given divine authority” has that authority bestowed on them, but its not inherent to them, so its always contingent on God continuing to bestow that power on them. Someone who “is divine” is inherently so, its a fact of their being and isn’t contingent on anything else.

      How would you distinguish between those two?

What do you think? I would love to hear from you, please share your thoughts. Just remember to be respectful of others.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s